The Rise and Fall of Manchester United: Why It Was Never Just About Sir Alex Ferguson
Updated: Sep 25
The year is 2013, Manchester United have just won the Premier League title again. Their 20th league title - their 13th in the Premier League era. Their 38th major trophy under the management of legendary manager Sir Alex Ferguson. They truly were the unstoppable force in English football.
Fast forward just over a decade, they are onto their 7th permanent manager. They have spent over £1 billion in the transfer market. And they are in their longest title drought since the 1980s. But what happened? How did this powerhouse, not just English football but world football, go from on top of the world to their worst period in years.
This is the rise, the fall and maybe the rise again of Manchester United.

In the late 1950s under the reign of the legendary manager Sir Matt Busby Manchester United had an exceptionally young but talented squad. The average age of the team at the time was just 22. And in 1956 and 1957 they won back-to-back league titles with that squad. Devastatingly though the success was cut short following the Munich Air Disaster in 1958. The club was hit hard by the tragedy but with Busby at the helm the team was rebuilt looking to honour all the players lost. In 1968 they did just that winning the European Cup with iconic names and former ballon d’Or winners like George Best, Denis Law and Sir Bobby Charlton - a survivor of the Munich Air Disaster - leading the team to victory.
It wasn’t all sunshine and rainbows at Old Trafford though because following that success the club went on a steep decline - eventually getting relegated in 1974. They managed FA Cup success in 1977 but then it wasn’t until 1983 that they would win another trophy. The club's longest ever trophy drought.
In 1986, a certain Scottish manager by the name of Alex Ferguson walked through the doors. Off the back of winning the Scottish League title with Aberdeen he would look to be the man to take the Red Devils back to the top. But it wasn’t easy. The club struggled during his first few years and in 1990 Ferguson looked destined for the sack. The club were on a winless run and sat 13th in the league. Many fans at the time believed that Ferguson would lose his job if he couldn’t provide domestic success. United went on to win the FA Cup against Crystal Palace essentially saving Ferguson's job.
Sir Alex Ferguson would stay at the club for the next 26 years. Dominating not just English football but world football as a whole. By his retirement in 2013, Ferguson had won everything there was to win in football. In 1999, he led the club to their famous treble, truly putting them on top of the world. But not only did Ferguson win everything there is to win, he managed and helped develop some of the greatest players this country has ever seen turning them from young talents to global superstars.. Wayne Rooney, Paul Scholes, Ryan Giggs, Roy Keane, Rio Ferdinand and who can forget Cristiano Ronaldo - to name a few.
When Alex Ferguson announced his retirement it sent shock waves through English football. Manchester United weren’t just the biggest team in England. They were one of the greatest footballing dynasties the game has ever seen. The squad he left behind was full of winners though, surely they would be fine. Well that’s what they might have thought but it certainly didn’t transpire that way.
After Sir Alex announced his decision to leave Manchester United and retire the question floated in the air of just who would take over and that was of course placed in the hands of “the chosen one” David Moyes. A man Sir Alex himself, had hand-picked. This is often seen as the moment where the club began to spiral but I’m not quite sure that it is.
Although the squad Sir Alex left behind was full of title winners, the squad was aging. Some of their better players were getting into their 30s and were not the players they once were. Moyes inherited what was a bit of a messy squad. And with no plan from the club as to what they would do after Sir Alex left to keep the squad alive.
Moyes didn’t even last a year in charge of the club getting the sack after just 10 months. But if you look at the transfer windows that he had to say I’m not surprised he struggled would be an understatement. As a fan watching I was frustrated because we had the players and we weren’t winning but in 2 transfer windows Moyes only signed two players - Marouane Fellaini and Juan Mata. He had even more deals for huge, established players fall through. Thiago almost joined, Fabregas was a target, even Bale was linked before his move to Madrid and none of them transpired. Even a player that went on to sign and become a cult hero at United Ander Herrera had a deal fall through. What a difference he could have made. Overall it was not enough to complete a rebuild and carry on the legacy that Sir Alex left.
From there it was a period of successful established managers coming in and not living up to expectation with Van Gaal and Mourinho both failing to succeed. Both despite the pedigree they had and the signings they made. Before moving on to Ole Gunnar Solskjaer who was sacked after nearly three years, Ralf Rangnick who was sacked after six months following a period of exposing United from the bottom up highlighting many issues that fans already knew and everyone else was beginning to see, Erik Ten Hag (sacked after two and a half years) and most recently Ruben Amorim who led the club to one of their worst periods in their history. Which naturally brings us to today and the appointment of Michael Carrick on an interim basis which has since turned permanent.
All of these managers - and it doesn’t even include all of the interims who took charge either. Managerially the team has been in an absolute state since Sir Alex left the club. But is this the reason for their decline? Have they just not found the right man? I don’t believe so.
Let's talk football strategy. Because to be quite honest there has been none since Sir Alex left. On the pitch there was no clear vision of how the club wanted to play. Appointing all these managers meant the club's style was constantly swapping and changing. Amorim didn’t play how Ten Hag played while Ten Hag didn’t play how Ole or Mourinho played. Everything was different.
Then the glaringly obvious factor… recruitment. Arguably Manchester United have become one of the biggest laughing stocks in the world when it comes to recruitment. Maybe on paper the moves they have made haven’t been all bad. They have, after all, brought in some incredibly big names over the years. But egos certainly got the better of them at times and with the amount of money spent you certainly would feel as though the Red Devils should be in a better place than they have been. Let's take a look at a few examples:
Jadon Sancho. In my opinion the worst signing in the post Fergie era. Signed by the club in 2021 off the back of a successful stint at Borussia Dortmund. The club signed him for £73 million. Sancho only made 58 appearances for the club scoring just nine times. Before his release from the club at the end of last season (2025/26) - due to the expiration of his contract - the last time he had played a game for the club was in 2023.
He did spend some time out on loan but it has to be said this is a disgrace. And it is not the manager's fault either. Sancho’s time at the club was worsened due to questions over his attitude and his relationship with the manager and staff. It appeared as though he was given every chance to succeed at the club. And yet he failed to take opportunities and never consistently performed at the standard of a £73 million player. Despite being a major transfer he truly did nothing for the club.
What about Antony? Signed for £82 million off the back of 18 goals in 57 appearances for Ajax in 2 years at the club. It started very well with what I saw personally as a terrific debut performance. That quickly turned sour with poor performance after poor performance on the pitch. Under the manager that he was somewhat successful with at Ajax the season prior.
These are just two examples. Over spending was the definition of Manchester United in this era. Pogba, Maguire, Lukaku, Di Maria to name a few are all big transfers - fairly big names as well that the club arguably over paid for. I will say I like Maguire and he can put in good performances now and again but was he ever worth the price tag that was paid for him? Absolutely not.
Recruitment issues aren't the only problem though. Everything off the pitch was falling apart as well. Which brings me onto what I think is the root cause of the problems at the club and that’s the Glazer family ownership. Under Sir Alex, United were able to paper over the cracks. Because we were so successful on the pitch nobody took notice of what was going on off it and where it led is the reason they have been so unsuccessful across the board.
Endless debts, fan protests, the previously mentioned recruitment issues all stemming back to the Glazer family and their disastrous running of Manchester United football club. Constantly from the outside looking in it has felt like the club is nothing but a way to make money for them - constantly taking money out and not putting nearly as much as they should back in.
And it isn’t just about the players and managers. Old Trafford for example has been declining for years, the training ground hadn’t been looked after either - Cristiano Ronaldo even said about it in that famous Piers Morgan interview a few years back. The cause of this United fall is almost certainly the Glazer family impact as owners of a club that just don’t care.
In comparison you look at Manchester City who have issues of their own. But their owners, whether we like what they are doing or not, have that club purely at the front of their minds. They have consistently invested in the clubs infrastructure, recruitment and coaching leading to success on the pitch and overall success for them in particular off it. This says a lot in comparison to Manchester United.
Or what about Arsenal? They have had ownership issues of their own but now they are in their most successful period on the pitch for over 20 years. Their recruitment has been near perfection. Everything behind the scenes in terms of how the club is run is sensational as well. Naturally providing results on the pitch.
This, something Man United don’t have and haven’t had for years.

Where do they go from here? Well where it isn’t all positive - trust me there are lots of negatives - there are certainly some (even if very few) steps in the right direction.
INEOS have come in and attempted to make changes to the club behind the scenes for better or worse. Including changes at the training ground, the proposed new stadium that the club hopes to build in the next few years and changes to their recruitment system as they look to not overpay on players in the same way they once were.
I do want to highlight a lot of negatives though. Sackings behind the scenes for example have sent the club into a bit of a mess with their clear lack of empathy towards anyone being clear as day. I wasn’t a fan of the sacking of Amorim not because his time at the club was good but the fact there was some improvement there and after he seemingly spoke out against the lack of support he had in the transfer window I felt his sacking was unjust. However we will never know the whole story of his sacking. There are certainly things to dislike about the club currently.
However, that being said for the first time in a long time, whether as a fan I like the plan or not, there does seem to be the making of a plan and a structure there. A new manager, a different approach in terms of recruitment with players coming in that are based on an idea of how the club should play rather than just on the reputation they uphold.
Man United’s fall was never just about one thing. It was never just the manager, or just the players. It was years of changing direction. Years of thinking “we are the best” without actually backing it up and proving it. The entitled “We are Manchester United” mindset has held the club back for a number of years. If things are going to turn around for the club, removing that mindset is going to be the first step. The club learning that fact will be the difference between success and declining even further.
Could this be the first step to taking Man United back to their glory days? For me I doubt it. There is a long way to go. But the rise of the club wasn't built overnight. It took decades. The fall, however, happened far quicker. Manchester United's problem was never that they lost Sir Alex Ferguson - every great era eventually comes to an end. The problem was that they never truly prepared for what came next. The next great Manchester United team will not be built by chasing the past. It will come from accepting that the club has to build something new.



Comments