top of page

Michael Carrick has been sacked by Manchester United - Who’s next for the hardest job in Football?

Writer: jgfcyt1
jgfcyt1
6 days ago
7 min read

Another season, another sacking.


Michael Carrick has officially been sacked as head coach of Manchester United. This brings an end to what has again been a very disappointing chapter in the club's post-Fergie history. In fact, I’d argue it has been the worst period in those 13 years.


After initially taking charge of the Red Devils on an interim basis, Carrick guided the club to a third-place league finish in 2025/26 before taking the role permanently. Since becoming the full-time boss though it has not been the same.


A disastrous start to the season provided a lot of disappointing performances as well as a lot of uproar in the stands that ultimately led to his departure. Even if the uproar was mostly targeted towards United’s owners and players rather than Carrick himself.


But where do the Red Devils go from here? Who will be the next person to take charge of the club? And ultimately will they be the one to finally take United back to the top? 


Stretford End of Old Trafford - Image: HonorTheKing / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 4.0.
Stretford End of Old Trafford - Image: HonorTheKing / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 4.0.

What does it take to be United’s manager?


I’d argue the job of Manchester United manager is the hardest job in club football. You not only have to deal with the pressure of returning United to the top but also pressures from the fans and the media. Then there’s the added issue of the owners who have proven at times incompetent in recent years - facing endless criticism from the fans.


But what do the fans want? How do you impress everyone?


Well first of all you have to win. It’s that simple. Win games and trophies. Even challenging for trophies at the highest level is important. The club has been too far away from that in recent years and it has left fans, and the owners for that matter, restless. Performing on the pitch and winning games is of course the most important. 


And secondly, I think playing entertaining football is incredibly important. Not only does winning get fans on side but being competitive does too. If the team plays boring, defensive football the fans won’t be on side and are more likely to turn when things go wrong. Having an attractive style of play makes all the difference.


Then there’s a handful of things. Maybe of less importance but still important in their own way. Being entertaining in the public eye in press conferences is beneficial, working well with the board and being adaptable on the pitch (this was the downfall of Ruben Amorim in the past in particular) to name a few. 


Who is next for Manchester United?


The Red Devils head coach role is a hard job to take on and those that do are certainly brave to do so. But then the achievement of being “the man to bring Man United back to the top” is surely too much to refuse. So who’s up for the position?


Mauricio Pochettino 


Pochettino has emerged as the favourite to take the position from Carrick in recent days according to David Ornstein.


Although currently in charge of the US Men's National Team it has been reported that he has a release clause in his contract. The former Chelsea, PSG and Tottenham Hotspur manager has been heavily favoured by the United hierarchy for a number of years often linked to the role so could this be his time?


In terms of pros, Poch has often shown that he can play entertaining football at all levels. He often leans towards attacking football which would be seen in a good light at United and he is proven in the Premier League which has often been seen positively by the owners of the club.


As well as this he has proven he is great at developing youth and he is well respected by the British media. 


But Pochettino does come with some questions. His struggles under tough ownership at Chelsea was clear, suggesting maybe he would struggle in the United environment. He also would come into the role with a lack of major silverware, something that cannot continue with the Red Devils. 
































Eddie Howe


Backed heavily by current technical director Jason Willcox, Howe is a strong option for United going forward. 


Much like other managers in the running, he is Premier League proven which is a strong argument to why he could get the job. As a manager who is respected by the media as well, being an English manager who started from the lowest of lows and worked his way up, it could be a good call. 


However many fans of the club would prefer not to have Howe in charge. His style of football is risky to say the least as proven by his time at Newcastle and he certainly doesn’t have the pedigree that maybe some of the other managers on this list have. 


But then again as a free agent it would cost the club nothing to bring him in and he would more likely take the role of a head coach in comparison to manager, another benefit in the eyes of the United board.


Julian Nagelsmann


A favourite amongst the fans, free agent Nagelsmann is another good option for the club.


Another manager with a positive style of play that would surely get the results despite his lack of Premier League experience. Nagelsmann has taken on various projects across his career and being such a young manager as well the former Germany and Bayern Munich boss could be perfect for a long term project.


Christopher Vivell is also already at the club and having worked with him before it could be a positive step in the backroom staff. Especially if under pressure Wilcox is also relieved of his duties in days to come - though unlikely. 


But could he handle the pressure of being at such a big club? And with a lack of Premier League experience as mentioned could he slip further down the rankings in the eyes of the board?


Antonio Conte


A serial winner it is clear why he is on the list of potential options for the Red Devils.


That is the main reason for him to take the job. Conte has a history of winning titles, especially in his first season at a club doing it with Chelsea, Napoli and Juventus prior to these rumours. 


Many United fans would be glad to see him come in mostly because of his strict coaching style. Many of the players have seemed lazy and unfit this season so Conte coming in will almost certainly change that. Plenty of running in training for sure. The results will come on the pitch under his regime.


The issue arises in the boardroom though with Conte almost certainly wanting full control while the United bosses are more likely to appoint a “yes man” coming in as a head coach rather than manager. Conte would almost certainly clash with the owners of the club on decisions so arguably is less likely to get the role because of this.


In terms of short term options though is anyone better than Conte?
































Other Names in the Running


There are a few options that have been thrown around in recent months that it could be but ultimately I see as less likely candidates.


Unai Emery has proven he is a fantastic manager but it will take too much money to get him out of Aston Villa and we can guarantee he won’t be on board with a head coach position over having full control as manager should that be the path United go down.


Gareth Southgate’s name is almost always mentioned in relation to Man United in recent years. He hasn’t taken on a role since stepping down as England boss after Euro 2024 and reports suggest he isn’t looking to get back into management any time soon. It isn’t completely unlikely but I’d perhaps lean towards it not happening rather than happening.


Other names in the hat according to multiple sources include Kieran McKenna, former Man United striker and manager Ole Gunnar Solskjaer and Didier Deschamps. With young up and coming coaches Cesc Fabregas (currently managing Como) and high flying Brighton boss Fabian Hurzeler also being linked to the job. All of which I see as incredibly unlikely. 


But who will it be?


The question on everyone’s mind right now is who is it going to be? Who will be the man to replace Carrick? The question of who I would personally appoint is drastically different to who I think the club will go with though.


In my opinion the correct man for the job is Julian Nagelsmann. However, that comes with some conditions. 


Nagelsmann is a young manager who can take United to success over a long period of time should he be successful but he needs the tools to be able to do so. Considering Wilcox has been in charge of the appointment and eventual sacking of the last three managers I think it is time to give someone else a try. 


For Nagelsmann to work, Vivell should be given a position in which he can work closely with the manager. They’ve proven they work well together during their time at RB Leipzig, where Nagelsmann was manager and Vivell was Technical Director, so let's build a backroom team that knows and trusts one another. Ideally former United interim Ralf Rangnick comes back in as well. but I can’t see that happening so let’s just make a team around Nagelsmann and Vivell. Build for the future. 


Do I think that will happen though? Absolutely not.


I think the most likely option to take the reins now that Carrick has gone is Mauricio Pochettino. And, as mentioned, Ornstein's reports suggest that talks are advancing with him.


A Premier League proven manager that has taken on some of the biggest roles in the world most notably at Paris Saint Germain. As well as the bonus of entertaining football and being good with the media he would probably be the perfect option in the eyes of those currently in charge. However, only time will tell. 


For now Carrick is gone and the future of Manchester United football club is up in the air. One thing is for certain though… whoever is picked will be backed by the fans. Ultimately it is just about whether the fans keep the attention on the main problem at the club - the ownership.


Then maybe, whoever the next manager is, can be the one to guide United back to the very top of football. 

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page