The Premier League’s Manchester City Problem - How I Would Punish The Citizens
The Premier League has a huge problem on their hands. Well, in fairness, they probably have more than just one huge problem on their hands, but that could be a post in itself. The specific problem I am talking about is Manchester City Football Club.
Recently something happened. And that something is being called one of the biggest scandals in English football history - maybe football history as a whole. An independent commission found Manchester City guilty of 115 breaches relating to inaccurate financial reporting, alleged disguised funding, breaking spending rules, payments to managers and players, and failing to cooperate with the Premier League. The list really feels like it goes on and on.
But now the Premier League and the wider English football pyramid have a problem on their hands - how do you punish Manchester City?
I will say despite the guilty verdict City have appealed the decision which will ultimately prolong the process of punishing them. I mean there is a chance that nothing will come of it. Current manager Enzo Maresca in his press conference today (at the time of writing) claimed that the owners of the club were “convinced” they will win their appeal and that the club is “absolutely not” tainted by commissions decision.
However this is a topic I find incredibly interesting and so I thought I’d share my opinion. If I was in charge, how would I punish Manchester City should their appeal fail and the guilty verdict stood?

Before I continue I do want to stress that I am a Manchester United fan if you didn’t already know. I’d quite like to come here and say I think Manchester City should be kicked out of the English football pyramid, forcing their owners to leave and ultimately ending the club's existence. But I do want to do this post with an element of truth to it.
Although I am not a Manchester City fan, the fans of the club shouldn’t be punished for something that they didn’t know was going on. Because ultimately it isn’t their fault and Man City whether I like them or not do have a long history being founded in 1880 and facing countless relegations and promotions along the way.
I don’t like them but I want to keep this post firstly realistic to something that could genuinely happen and secondly as unbiased as a Manchester United fan writing about punishing Manchester City could be.
That brings me on to the first thing I think should happen and that is a huge points deduction. And genuinely I think this is one of the things that will happen should the appeal fail.
The Premier League and all of English football for that matter don’t often shy away from giving clubs points deductions for breaking rules - especially in recent years. Everton, for example, are a long-standing Premier League club and were given a points deduction just a few seasons ago after breaching the league's financial rules. In comparison to Manchester City’s charge, Everton’s breach looks like nothing.
It would be an incredibly huge double standard to punish City differently to the likes of Everton for example when the breach is considerably differing amounts. If one club can be punished for breaking the rules then the same principles should stand for another club. Especially in this case where the differing breaches are so significant.
For me though a deduction of points dropping them to the Championship may not be enough. All that will most likely happen with that is they will come straight back up at the first time of asking and ultimately nothing would have significantly changed.
This is where the Premier League and EFL need to come together as different governing bodies serving the purpose of deducting potentially more points.
In my opinion the points deduction cannot be of the amount of points it is to relegate them from the Premier League only for them to get straight back up. It should instead be a concurrent points deduction across multiple seasons restricting their likelihood of returning to the top flight instantly.
36 points is often enough to survive in the Premier League so lets restrict them completely. Deduct 70+ points from them in 4 consecutive seasons ultimately forcing relegation on them.
Alternatively you could give them a huge points deduction this season so they are relegated and then face further sanctions that could drop them further down the pyramid - potentially proposing to start in EFL League Two. Make it a mission for them to get back up. It shouldn’t be a one season thing.
My punishment wouldn’t stop purely at points deduction though. The next thing I would personally propose is a long standing transfer ban. Maybe of two or three seasons. This restricting the money they can spend to bring in players to replace those that will inevitably leave should the club be relegated.
Again we have seen transfer bans take place before. It wasn’t that long ago that Chelsea were struck with a transfer ban following breaches of regulations in regards to signing young players. Even though the sanctions were different it shows that a transfer ban could be a very real possibility. Especially considering it has happened before.
If Man City were found to have committed serious transfer breaches again it would be a double standard to not hit them with a transfer ban. Especially considering it has applied to other clubs in the past. A long standing ban rather than just a one season ban would make sure that the punishment has a lasting impact. The club shouldn’t be allowed to just buy their way back to the top.
Ultimately the punishments I have in mind restrict them from being back in the top flight for a prolonged period of time. Relegate them and make sure they can’t spend money so it is harder for them to get back to the top.
My third and final punishment idea - should City’s appeal not work - is a huge fine. I think it is the most likely option of what will happen as well but maybe not to the degree I was thinking.
I think about all the clubs who have lost out thanks to City’s potential wrongdoing. Clubs that have failed to win the title, clubs that have missed out on the top 4 or European places as a whole, clubs who have been relegated. For me there should be some form of compensation paid to them.
That is why my fine to them would be split into two sections. One that is paid to the Premier League directly, as fines often are, but another that is paid to clubs that can prove they were directly affected by the breaches. I couldn’t tell you a specific number but it would surely be a lot.
Take qualifying for the UEFA Champions League for example. Clubs receive a substantial amount of money for just qualifying so to finish fifth rather than fourth for example and just miss out could play a massive part in clubs the following season.
And what about just being in the top tier of English football? The differences between Premier League survival and relegation? The revenue Premier League clubs generate is insane so imagine missing out on that sort of money and that sort of exposure primarily because one club gained an unfair advantage.
Compensation to some degree needs to be paid. And that is on top of a fine that will surely go to the Premier League as well, especially considering their failing to comply with the Premier League potential breach.
I did want to touch on something that I am not including in my list. That being stripping the club of the trophies won on the pitch. Potentially giving them to the second placed teams instead. For me though that isn’t a punishment I can see happening, nor would I necessarily do it.
In a way, I do feel it would be a just punishment. If the appeal fails the overall view will be that they ultimately cheated their way to success. They gained an unfair advantage, so to take their titles away from them would make a lot of sense. However this is not something I necessarily see as fair.
Similarly to the fans we can’t be overly sure if the players on the pitch actually knew that the breaches were taking place. And at the same time the accomplishments of the team on the pitch shouldn’t be taken away from them - even if I would love for them to lose their trophies as a fan of the Red Devils.
For me this comes under the compensation punishment that I previously mentioned. Rather than taking their trophies and giving them to teams the punishment comes from them having to pay compensation to any teams that may or may not have missed out on things because of it. Whether that be finishing second, missing out on European qualification or relegation as a result of the breaches. Thus why I am not including the much discussed removing trophies and medals on my list.
Ultimately, that is how I would punish Man City should their appeal fail and the guilty verdict remains. I would give them a huge points deduction, a lengthy transfer ban and hit them with a fine to be paid to the Premier League and teams that can prove they were directly affected by the breaches as compensation. For me this is the fairest way to punish them.
And to conclude I want to say, if the appeal does fail and the guilty verdict remains a punishment needs to happen. The Premier League is the best league in the world so for a team like Manchester City to have unfairly stayed at the top of the league for so long as the dominant force in the league everyone in England takes a hit. The credibility of the top tier of English football would take a massive hit.
Whatever happens, Man City will face scrutiny. The outcome will more than likely affect the rest of their season and beyond. If the guilty verdict stands, there needs to be a punishment. Whether it is what I’ve said here or something else. The most important thing is that there are consequences.



Comments