top of page

Manchester United Are a Mess - Is it Time to Sack Michael Carrick?

Writer: jgfcyt1
jgfcyt1
Oct 22
9 min read

Seven years ago, Como 1907 were playing in Serie D. Last night, they beat Manchester United in the UEFA Champions League. And, unfortunate as it may be, I am not here to talk about Como and their success. Props to them they deserved it. 


Instead I am here, as a Man United fan, to talk about the absolute disaster that is Manchester United Football Club at the moment. Because the place is an absolute mess and the worst state they have EVER been in.


I don’t take those words lightly but it is true. The worst start to a season in 40+ years. At the time of writing they haven’t won a game in seven. In fact they have only won two games this season, Ipswich and Sabah. This is a disgrace. 


Let's talk about the absolute state of the club and where the Red Devils need to go from here because this can’t go on any longer. This is the worst period in Manchester United post Fergie.


David Dixon / The East Stand, Old Trafford Stadium /  CC BY-SA 2.0 
David Dixon / The East Stand, Old Trafford Stadium /  CC BY-SA 2.0 

I can’t help but feel the best place to start here is the manager. Or the head coach because Michael Carrick is not a manager. Not at this club at least. 


I will say I love Carrick. What a player he was. One of the most underrated players England has ever had. He was astonishing. As the song goes “It’s Carrick you know. It’s hard to believe it’s not Scholes”. His legacy at the club is unmatched. But there’s one huge but here. That is as a player. Not a manager. Not a head coach. 


For weeks it has been proven that he is simply not good enough and last night’s game against Como in the Champions League emphasised that even more. On a week where we were told the players had “the best training session” and after a draw to Leeds, where many saw some positive signs (not me by the way I thought the manner of that draw was atrocious), this game was a chance to kick on. 


In our last European game against Atletico Madrid, United conceded in one minute. Yesterday they conceded in two. Horrific! Most teams when they concede early on get a bit of a kick and think hey we need to sort ourselves out and go on to push on. Maybe even sort themselves out completely. Not this Manchester United team under Carrick though. Instead the Red Devils failed to register a shot on target in the first half. And I can’t help but feel Carrick is the problem.


People that know me will know I am never quick to jump on the manager. We have seen this before and will more than likely go down the same route again so always back the manager. I was backing Ole till the end, Ten Hag until the last moment, I even disagreed with the sacking of Amorim completely. This is different.


We simply cannot accept mediocrity at this football club. And that is exactly what we have. Carrick is not good enough.


Many may argue the point of last season's success. On the surface that is a valid argument. How though, this season, do the players look lethargic? Unfit? Amorim left the club and one thing he did was make sure every player was game ready and fit. I would run and press as much as possible. The players were fit last season but they certainly aren’t this season and I can’t help but feel that is because of the coaching staff. 


We were playing one game a week last season because we had no European football. Carrick took charge of a fitter, more game ready squad. A squad that were playing their hearts out. Look at Bruno Fernandes who set the assist record last season, Casemiro who was solid as a rock in the midfield (and wasn’t replaced properly), or even Harry Maguire and Luke Shaw who were playing with the aim of going to the World Cup. Where are they now?


Michael Carrick has been exposed this season. He just simply isn’t good enough. And if he loves this club as much as I am sure he does and he so often says he does maybe the right thing to do is leave. For the benefit of the club. Considering he hasn’t been sacked already which in itself is shocking and something I will get on to it is best for him to just leave. 


This is not against the man nor the player. This is against the head coach and Carrick is by no means good enough. 

































Carrick is not the only thing going wrong at the club though. Especially when you have two players. Two senior players for that matter - one of which being our captain - speaking out against the club. 


Following the game against Atletico Madrid, Lisandro Martinez came out on national television and spoke out against the way the club has been run. Especially in regard to the transfer window just gone.


“I have to control myself a lot, but sometimes it’s a reflection of how our club is at the moment.” He said.


“We had a fantastic season last season, and now we expect more from the top, from upstairs, to bring in more players to compete because many teams have brought in many players as well.”


“I expect more from our technical director. I have to be honest.”


Speaking out like that for me is very telling. And although he issued somewhat of an apology in the days that followed I can’t help but feel like he knew what he was saying and he truly believed it. Martinez knows that United aren’t good enough at the moment and came out and said what every fan knows and feels. It isn’t good enough.


































Then following the game last night against Como, club captain Fernandes also came out and struck out against the club in an interview. More so on the coaches but also about how United ultimately aren’t good enough to compete anymore.


“We’re not in the past, we need to look into the future.” said the captain of the club. 


“Unfortunately for us - as a group of players - every time you come to this club you think about winning games, winning trophies and being at the highest level. Unfortunately, it has been very difficult at this club in the last few years.”


Also commenting on the coaches and the way United played in the game Fernandes claimed, “It’s a decision from the staff to not press man-to-man and sometimes leave a little space in behind and try to get the ball in the first moment, to wait for them, to give them the ball”


“But sometimes when you give too much the ball to these teams they get confident, they have so many bodies behind the ball that make you run a lot, make people get frustrated, and then obviously when you recover the ball the legs are, and the brain, much more difficult to make it work.”


“That’s on the manager and the staff to see it, it’s not on me”

























This damning assessment of the game is the most telling for me. Martinez speaking out is one thing but Fernandes is a completely different kettle of fish. This is the club captain. The PFA Player of the Year. The best player the club has had since Sir Alex Ferguson retired by an absolute long shot. The one person that is always there for the club and lives and breathes the club.


But this is not just a nail in the coffin of Carrick. The part I find most interesting is not his comments about the head coach. Instead it’s his comments about the fact that ultimately the club isn’t good enough. Ultimately, Fernandes came into that interview and once again much like Martinez said exactly what the fans know and the fans believe. The club isn’t good enough anymore. It’s a warning shot to anyone that might think to join the club in the future that we aren’t going to win anything. Not in this current moment anyway.


A lot of the media and ex players are coming out speaking about how much of a disgrace it is that Fernandes is saying this sort of thing after a game. Many did the same against Martinez. But one thing is for sure. The fans aren’t reacting badly. The fans, the people that support and follow the club week in week out and know the club better than most, are standing with the captain.


For two senior players in the last week or so to come out and speak so openly and so anti the current club situation is not only brave but just proves that the players know this isn’t right. I can’t help but feel many will feel the exact same in the dressing room but are too afraid to speak out. 


This might mean the end of both Martinez and Fernandes at this football club but what they have said speaks volumes and looks even worse on the club's situation. Something we have never had before.


And that brings me on to the final point I want to make and that is about ownership. INEOS and the Glazers. Somehow the eyes aren’t purely on the Glazers but rightly so because INEOS are the main ones to blame here. All I can say is they need to get out or sort it out. Fans lost faith a long time ago and yet somehow it is still getting worse.


The recruitment in the summer was shocking first of all. A midfield rebuild was needed and we got three midfielders that were barely on the radar before the window began. Especially considering everyone was talking about the likes of Elliot Anderson, Sandro Tonali and Matheus Fernandes. Not only that but the failure to bring in a striker or a defender - specifically a left back in particular - has left us in ruins. 


The squad looks empty and incomplete. I have pretty openly spoken here already about how I think Carrick needs to go but in a way I think how could he help himself with the tools at his disposal. A lack of care in the window is clear. Yet everything is a cover up. To defend themselves. 


Everything INEOS have done has just seen the club get worse and worse because they know nothing about football. They know nothing about running a club. Yet they think they know everything. 


Erik Ten Hag, our former manager, did an interview himself this week and spoke pretty openly about his time at the club. One thing I found particularly interesting though were his comments about INEOS and their involvement.


“I offered my knowledge and abilities to INEOS to help them to construct, but they were of the opinion that they already knew everything.” he said.


“They were convinced of, say, the philosophy, the strategy, the work methods. But they came from petrochemicals, from Formula 1, from cycling. Top football demands something totally different.”



































The reason I find this particularly interesting is that Ten Hag came from a club that is known for data. One of the best clubs in the world at that. He claims to offer them the help and yet apparently they know everything. How?!


Look at where the club has gone since that. In what universe has anything INEOS has done been beneficial to the club and proven Ten Hag wrong and that they know things. Clearly they do not.


I’d respect it if they came out and said “We got it wrong with Carrick” and sacked him as well as Jason Wilcox who was behind recruitment and Carrick’s hiring in the first place - as well as Ruben Amorim’s hiring and sacking. Starting fresh. I don’t have to like them after that but I can respect that. But I know and you know they won’t do that. This cycle will continue unless something at the club changes. Everything from the top down is a mess and INEOS are the ones behind it. Maybe we should have listened to the Nice fans that tried to warn us.


Ultimately, Manchester United from the top down are a mess. But how can we change that? It’s easy for me to say that we have to get rid of the owners because it isn’t necessarily as easy as that. 


The first step needs to be getting rid of Carrick and Wilcox. Hiring Antonio Conte, Julian Naglesmann, Eddie Howe - all of which are experienced and available managers by the way. As well as a technical director for them to work under that is at least competent. This is a short term success though.


The owners need to go. INEOS need to go. Fans need to band together, protest, target sponsors, not attend games, anything to get them out. Because as long as Sir Jim Ratcliffe, INEOS and The Glazers are in charge it only gets worse and worse. Soon there will be no coming back.


Manchester United are a mess and until we do something about it it is only going to get worse and worse.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page