top of page

Should Premier League Games be Played in America? A Fans Perspective

Writer: jgfcyt1
jgfcyt1
Sep 27
6 min read

I’ll be honest… I am not a regular listener of TalkSport. I only really pay attention through clips on social media or if I am on a long journey and desperate to hear what's going on in a specific fixture. That being said I do feel as though some of the conversations they have are interesting. Sparking plenty of debate.


Anyway this isn’t a post about TalkSport but a post about a conversation I specifically heard on there in my quest to hear what was going on between Portugal and Wales recently. And it certainly hooked me. 


The topic in question? The potential of Premier League fixtures being played in the US. 


It got me thinking about the current Premier League set up, the future of the league and the supporters of clubs up and down the English pyramid and whether or not they would agree or disagree on the topic. 


So why not use my platform to have my say, ultimately answering the question…


Should the Premier League consider American fixtures?


FIFA World Cup Final 2026 - Photo: Bryan Berlin / Wikimedia Commons — CC BY-SA 4.0
FIFA World Cup Final 2026 - Photo: Bryan Berlin / Wikimedia Commons — CC BY-SA 4.0

Before we answer that I think we need to answer another, more obvious question. Why America? If the Premier League is going to take games abroad, why do it in the United States? Is it all about money or is there more to the story?


Well to be honest I do think the majority of the reason would be about money. But that isn’t the whole reason. The US provides an opportunity for the Premier League that is something I’m sure they cannot ignore. 


Whether us British people want to admit it or not, the United States is a powerhouse in the sporting world. They have built some of the biggest sporting dynasties the world has ever seen with the likes of the NFL, NBA, MLB, NHL and so many more generating billions of dollars every single year. The NFL for example has generated over $23 billion and is expected to continue to grow. This is due to the sheer force of the sporting world there. A world that is slowly being cracked by football as well.


Football as a whole continues to grow in popularity in the US. Especially with the most recent FIFA World Cup happening in America, the continued growth of the MLS, Stars like Lionel Messi, Casemiro, Heung Min Son and many more choosing to play there, and the continued visit from sides across the world including England during pre season. The game isn’t at the level there as the likes of the previously mentioned NFL for example but it is certainly growing at a rapid rate. The Premier League included. 


Photo: A. Smith / Wikimedia Commons — CC BY-SA 3.0
Photo: A. Smith / Wikimedia Commons — CC BY-SA 3.0

Playing games in America means not just more money but more opportunity for the league to grow. New audiences, new sponsors, new broadcasters, new commercial opportunities and so much more. It is surely a no brainer that the Premier League would consider US fixtures for this reason. It is just whether the opportunity is worth sacrificing for.


Ultimately, I don’t actually think that the Premier League or the teams in the league are going to be the ones that make the decision. It will be the fans. Sure the Premier League can say yes and announce it but that doesn’t necessarily mean that it is going to happen.


Look at La Liga for example. In 2025, La Liga announced that the US would host La Liga Miami. A game between Villarreal and Barcelona that would take place in Miami a few months after the announcement in December. The backlash was incredible. So much so that just under two weeks later the plan was scrapped. The game took place in Spain as originally planned - Barca coming away 2-0 victors. 


The fans from my point of view have all the power and rightly so. The decision to play games abroad if it were to happen would have a massive effect and would surely generate huge backlash especially from loyal supporters who watch their teams home and away.  


I mean imagine paying hundreds if not thousands to watch your team week in week out and one day it is announced that the club is playing a game in the US. And not just a random pre-season friendly either. A fully competitive matchup in the Premier League. It is one thing paying for a train ticket from Manchester to London on a matchday for example. Now imagine having to pay out for a flight to Los Angeles or New York instead. The average match going fan of a football club is now stuck in an impossible scenario. 


The relationship that a person has with the team they support is like no other. And it is something that can span generations. A relationship in itself that I would argue has built the English game to be what it is today. I can’t help but feel a rendition of You’ll Never Walk Alone would have the same impact in the Mercedes-Benz Stadium in Atlanta compared to on a night under the lights at Anfield. Or even the noise from the stand behind the goal at the BMO Stadium that you do when Manchester United score in front of the Stretford End. 



In my opinion this should be considered the biggest immediate concern for the Premier League in regard to bringing games to the US. Because it isn’t about whether or not Americans should be able to watch the games, it is about the experience changing for the average fan.


Despite all of this, are there fans out there that would support this idea? I mean lets take Wrexham for example. An incredibly devoted fanbase and culture surround the club but the view of the club in recent years has transitioned with American ownership taking place. 


Rob McElhenney and Ryan Reynolds have worked wonders at Wrexham there is no doubt about that. They in my opinion represent American investment that has worked perfectly especially if you consider the now global reach of a club that may not have had it in the past in Wrexham. So would their fans be more open to a potential game in the US should they get promoted to the Premier League? Would taking a game across the pond to them feel like just a part of their journey compared to at another club who hasn’t had the same American investment in the club?


Wrexham is of course just an example of potential changes. Maybe a Wrexham vs Birmingham match played in the US could be an intriguing prospect. Maybe fans would be against the idea of a US hosted fixture entirely. But ultimately you never really know. 
























And I think this is the most interesting thing about this debate. Ultimately we won’t know unless it happens. Maybe writing this from my perspective as a British football fan I lean towards one way of thinking more so than others. Is there an argument to say an American Premier League fan, although they love the club they support, would rather not see them play in the US. I’m sure it is a massive experience for them to travel in order to support their team from their actual stadium for example.


If I had to give my take on the situation - which I suppose I do have to this is my article after all - I’d say the idea of bringing a Premier League game to the US is something that should absolutely not happen. And I feel the vast majority of supporters would feel the exact same way. 


This is not to say that I can’t see the reasoning why the Premier League might want to. I mean it does make a lot of sense. But the idea of taking the sport that is so loved in this country away for the pure reason that the league wants to increase its reach (if not purely about money) is ridiculous. 


Football isn’t the NFL or the NBA and I think that’s what makes it so unique. 


The Premier League is already a global product. As proven by the increase of Premier League fans in the US for example. This doesn’t mean that competitive Premier League games should be played there. There is nothing wrong with the idea of increasing eyes on the Premier League, more American supporters and ultimately more money. The Premier League is after all a business. But football isn’t a product. You can’t put a price on it.


However, like I previously mentioned we aren’t going to know how people would react unless it does happen. If it happens, maybe fans will like it. Maybe (more likely) they won’t. But do I think they should? No. The world may love the Premier League but England is where it belongs. So let’s keep it there.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page